Warren Buffett has long cautioned that the price-to-earnings, or P/E, ratio is not a reliable shortcut for figuring out whether a stock is cheap or expensive. His core argument is that a low P/E can make a bad business look like a bargain, while a high P/E can undervalue a truly great one. In his view, the ratio is a starting point at best, not a verdict, because it says nothing about the quality, durability, or growth potential of the earnings behind it.

The P/E ratio is calculated by dividing a company's share price by its earnings per share. Investors have used it for generations as a quick gauge of valuation: a lower number supposedly signals a cheaper stock, a higher number a pricier one. Buffett's objection is not that the math is wrong, but that the number by itself tells you almost nothing about the business generating those earnings. A company could have a low P/E because it is genuinely undervalued, or because its earnings are declining, unsustainable, or propped up by one-time gains. Without digging deeper, an investor cannot tell the difference.

This skepticism flows directly from Buffett's broader investment philosophy, which he developed under the influence of value-investing principles centered on intrinsic worth rather than market price. He has repeatedly said that price and value are different things, famously summarizing the distinction as "price is what you pay, value is what you get." A stock's P/E ratio reflects price relative to current earnings, but it says little about what the business is actually worth based on its future cash-generating ability.

Buffett has instead emphasized looking at what he calls owner earnings, a measure of the cash a business could distribute to shareholders after accounting for the reinvestment needed to maintain its competitive position. He has also stressed the importance of understanding a company's durable competitive advantage, or economic moat, the quality of its management, its use of debt, and its return on invested capital. These factors shape whether today's earnings are likely to grow, shrink, or evaporate, something a single P/E figure cannot capture.

A related point Buffett has made is that paying a higher multiple for an exceptional business can be far better than paying a low multiple for a mediocre one. He has described preferring to own a wonderful company at a fair price over a fair company at a wonderful price. In practice, that means a stock with a seemingly elevated P/E ratio may still be attractively priced if the business can compound earnings at a high rate for many years, while a stock with a rock-bottom P/E may be a poor investment if its earnings are structurally impaired or about to decline.

Buffett has also warned that P/E ratios can be distorted by accounting choices, cyclical swings in profits, debt levels, and one-off items such as asset sales or write-downs. Two companies with identical P/E ratios can have very different risk profiles once leverage, cash reserves, and the sustainability of margins are taken into account. For this reason, he has generally avoided making investment decisions based on screening for low multiples alone, a practice sometimes associated with simplistic value investing.

This does not mean Buffett ignores valuation altogether. He has been clear that price still matters enormously and that overpaying for even an excellent business can produce poor returns. His point is narrower: the P/E ratio is one data point among many, and using it in isolation, without assessing the strength of the underlying business and the reliability of its earnings, can lead investors to misjudge both risk and opportunity.

For everyday investors, the practical takeaway from Buffett's comments is to treat the P/E ratio as a conversation starter rather than a conclusion. A low ratio invites questions about why the market is pricing a stock cheaply, while a high ratio invites questions about whether the growth or quality implied by that price is realistic. Answering those questions requires looking at financial statements, competitive positioning, and management decisions over time, not just a single number pulled from a stock quote.

Buffett's broader message, repeated across decades of public commentary, is that investing success comes from understanding businesses, not from mechanically applying valuation formulas. The P/E ratio can be a useful piece of context, but in his framework it is subordinate to the harder work of assessing what a company is actually worth and whether its earnings can be trusted to persist.